52 Weeks of Historical How-To’s, Week 24: Singing the Collections

Thursday 10 April 2014
Some of the choir in action
Some of the choir in action
How to sing ‘doh’ from The Elements of Singing, St Andrews copy at sM1.A4M6 147
How to sing ‘doh’ from The Elements of Singing, St Andrews copy at sM1.A4M6;147

This week’s blog is about the fun we have had singing together, learning songs chosen from the undiscovered riches of the Library’s music holdings. We have explored the hidden depths of many of our staff during this blog series and, during the trawl for talent at the beginning, a few of us confessed to musical abilities of various sorts. We could concoct only a very strange ensemble of instruments, but we did see potential in trying to get a singing group together. So Briony and I put out a call to the wider library to see whether there were other singers who might join a blog choir. Since the end of January we have been meeting in a lunchbreak once a week in the inspiring surroundings and beautiful acoustic of St Leonards Chapel to rehearse. Our blog choir was made up of sopranos: Janet Aucock, Aileen Cook, Vicki Cormie, Elizabeth Cuthill; altos: Briony Aitchison, Catriona Foote, Rachel Hart, Kirsty Lee; and baritones: Eddie Martin, Norman Reid, Jeremy Upton. Dr Jane Pettegree, Director of Teaching in the Department of Music, generously gave of her time to arrange music, teach and accompany us and to craft a coherent group from our rather random selection of voices.

St Leonard's Chapel_1
St Leonard’s Chapel
Old photo with N and E_1
Our Choir
Dr Jane Pettegree moulded us into a choir
Dr Jane Pettegree moulded us into a choir

Jane says: “St Andrews University has hosted many fine high quality choirs and ensembles, including the flagship chapel choir, capable of delivering public performances of professional standard and of leading worship in chapel. Alongside of this, however, music has also traditionally functioned in St Andrews as a social activity; for many students, their experience of community in St Andrews is shaped by song. The music chosen for this blog illustrates different aspects of amateur, recreational singing: the singers aren’t students, but work together, and we have enjoyed each others’ company as we’ve worked on this material during lunch breaks.

B&W choir group_1
Our lunchtime choir practice.

In selecting the material, my starting point was, in common with many amateur music making projects, to find music that fitted our idiosyncratic group of singers. We had three good baritones to work with, but no tenors; we had women with lovely voices but different levels of music reading ability. To help us gel as a group, I chose some 19th century vocal exercises based on developing tone and interval recognition; we practised these a lot in the initial stages of the program and they helped us work out what sort of noises we all made together. Blending vowels is a good starting place for all choirs.

s MI A4MG 249 A Treatise on Singing_1_1
A Treatise on Singing where Mr Hunter says: ‘Compressing the Breast gently, (the lower part), by laying the arms across it, will assist a weak Voice’ St Andrews copy at sM1A4M6;249.
warm up 2_1
Here’s us obeying the instructions!
s MI A4MG 356 Vocal ex 1a Instructions in the art of singing_1_1
Instructions in the Art of Singing St Andrews copy, sMI.A4MG; 356

We practised in the beautiful reconstructed medieval St Leonards chapel, which has a lovely warm acoustic that is very satisfying for small choirs. The oldest piece in the program was partly chosen to suite this space. The ‘Motet against the Plague’ is a three part motet, probably written for all-female voices. The lowest part was presented in the tenor clef, but was singable by altos and (down an octave) by our baritones. What we’ve recorded is an adaptation of what we found in the Finzi collection copy, but we all really enjoyed how its clear, open sonorities worked in the space.

motet 1&2
Jane arranged this original from the Finzi collection into three parts for us. It is our favourite recording. ‘Motet against the Plague’ score at Fin MI.S68

The Finzi collection includes some very interesting early collections of Scots songs, a legacy from the period when Scottish antiquarians and musicians (including Robert Burns) rescued a fast-vanishing oral tradition. Songs like ‘Farewell to Lochaber’ and ‘The De’ils awa’ wi’ th’Exciseman’ combine late 18th century / early 19th century ideas about setting and accompaniment with melodic idioms that are much older. This is a resource that can either be used unmediated (we just took what was supplied for ‘The De’ils awa’’) or as the basis for a fresh arrangement (‘Farewell to Lochaber’ was reset for 3 parts using the piano accompaniment as a starting point). These songs reflect what would have been heard in parlours around Scotland in the 19th and earlier part of the 20th centuries, [and pretty mournful they are on occasion]; resources like these were key to the compositions of many Scottish composers, including Cedric Thorpe Davie, whose papers are held by Special Collections.

Fin M1746 E7 Scots Song Lochaber_1
Lovely Scots ballad.
Fin M1746 E7 Scots Songs The De'il's awa_1
Difficult to get all these words pronounced correctly – thanks for the advice, Norman!

Jane continues: “In student circles all around Scotland, the Scottish Student Song Book was the starting point for many noisy evenings of music making. In this referendum year I chose one for each side of the debate: ‘The British Grenadiers’ vs ‘Scot’s Wha Hae Wi’ Wallace Bled’. Both are part of our musical inheritance. Whatever the outcome of the vote this year, the sentiments expressed in ‘The Examiner’s Song’ (from the same book) proved still to be topical. However, after singing this through a few times, we decided not to record it – the words were very dated and the music wasn’t very inspiring!

StA M1965 S4S7 British Grenadiers_1
The British Grenadiers from the Student Song Book 
StA M1965 S4S7 Scots Wha Hae_1
Scots, Wha Hae from the Scottish Students Song Book

Finally, we dipped into an Edwardian collection of songs based on the Rudyard Kipling ‘Just So’ stories, for ‘The Camel’s Hump’. This was probably a solo vehicle rather than written for choirs (the tempo changes, for example, are much easily managed by a lone singer). The song does, however, reach back to a repertoire of ‘good clean fun’; we started singing it with our tongues firmly in our cheeks (if that’s physically possible), and ended by being rather charmed by its simplicity.”

Chi PR4854 5894 Just so song book_1_1
The Camel’s Hump from the Just So Song Book (Chi PR4854.J8G4)

Some of the singers remain very enthusiastic, over two months after we started practising:

I am really enjoying singing with the choir at lunchtimes, it is such a wonderful way of switching off work for an hour. I’ve only ever sung with one small informal choir before and I was completely lacking confidence, but the relaxed and fun atmosphere we’ve been sharing has made me forget about fears and just let me enjoy singing. The range of music has been really interesting, and I’ve been fascinated by the Motet against the plague, particularly the fact that it was written for women to sing as a protection for other women. I think the Library or even the University should have a fun lunchtime choir on a permanent basis, I am sure it would improve productivity in the afternoons! (Vicki)

_LIB1114_1I was interested in taking part because I enjoy singing, something which I haven’t done for a very long time. I also thought that this was a great way to interact with Special Collections’ material, and that it offered the opportunity to experience music not only from different time periods, but also from different genres. Where else would you get to sing a motet to the plague alongside a Kipling poem set to music? At first it felt quite challenging to be singing in such a small group (being somewhat out of practice), but I think that as the weeks have progressed we’ve all become more confident. I was hoping that more library staff would have volunteered for the choir, having envisaged something sizable for this project, but I believe we’re working really well as a small group; as the weeks go by, the more practicing we’re doing is certainly paying off. I’d love it if this choir could continue after the blog, exploring more of the music which Special Collections has to offer! (Briony)

_LIB1103_1I’ve very much enjoyed the Library choristers. I can’t say that I ever expected to be singing the British Grenadiers (which is a challenge to my world view in so many ways!), or a song about the Camel’s Hump. The motet against the plague was more in my sights, and was undoubtedly my favourite piece – but the variety was stimulating, I have to admit. Yet again, we are reminded of just how eclectic our collections are. The collegiality of joining with colleagues from different parts of the Library was great too – maybe it should become a permanent feature of Library life. (Norman)

Kirsty_1This has been an exhilarating experience for me. As a person who’ll try anything once (almost) I was keen to have a go! However, having never sung before (other than in the shower or when vacuuming), or had a choral background at school I found it most challenging when faced with a sheet of music that I couldn’t actually read! Fortunately, my fellow 2nd Soprano, Rachel, was my audible guide and once the tune was in my head I was set. I’ve had such a lot of fun and am particularly proud that I’ve participated in something that others can hopefully enjoy and appreciate. (Kirsty)

And Aileen’s reasons she enjoys the blog choir really sum up the experience for all of us:

my boss_1
My boss!

• To sing something different, specifically about camels, examiners and the plague.

• To not think about work – impossible to do so when singing.

• To see – and hear – a different side to colleagues – I found out my boss has a lovely singing voice (pay rise please).

• And it has been great fun!

Banner image for post_1

We’ve got a few more sessions lined up and then the ‘blog choir’ will take a break for the summer. But we hope to perform some of the items featured here, alongside other works from Special Collections, at an informal concert sometime in the Autumn – we’ll be sure to cover it on the blog!

-Rachel Hart

PS Thanks to Marc Boulay for coming to one of our practices and taking great photos!


Related topics

7 thoughts on "52 Weeks of Historical How-To’s, Week 24: Singing the Collections"

  • Christine Gascoigne
    Christine Gascoigne
    Thursday 10 April 2014, 12.18pm

    It sounds great fun. I wish I had been there! Christine

    • rachelmhart
      Thursday 10 April 2014, 7.56pm

      Thanks Christine - it would have been lovely to have had you - and Jane's arrangements could have included a tenor line! RH

  • joycecormie
    Thursday 10 April 2014, 2.13pm

    What fun. Can't wait for your concert!

  • Karen McAulay
    Karen McAulay
    Tuesday 15 April 2014, 11.09am

    FANTASTIC! A truly brilliant idea. I’ll read this properly later on today when I’ve finished catching up with my email backlog. Dr. Karen McAulay Music and Academic Services Librarian +44 (0)141 270 8267 (direct) [email protected] Author of, ‘Our Ancient National Airs: Scottish Song Collecting from the Enlightenment to the Romantic Era’ What's On Feb 14 - June 14 Prospectus Short Courses Prospectus 2013/14 Summer Schools [cid:[email protected]] [cid:[email protected]] Follow us on Facebook [cid:[email protected]] Follow us on Twitter [cid:[email protected]] Broadcast - Explore our digital hub

  • Public Engagement : Obligations to an Unknown Audience | Karen McAulay Teaching Artist
    Sunday 2 November 2014, 11.49pm

    […] the formation of a small but enthusiastic library choir to explore some historic song books: 52 Weeks of Historical How-Tos: Week 24: Singing the Collections.[3] Alternatively, the repertoire of a corpus of material might make an interesting focus for an […]

  • 52 Weeks of Historical How-To’s: Reflections and Visual Index | Echoes from the Vault
    Thursday 6 November 2014, 5.52pm

    […] One of the clearest benefits for us was in sharing the load, with a much wider participation in producing blog posts. 52 Weeks of Fantastic Bindings was written entirely by Daryl Green. 52 Weeks of Inspiring Illustrations was the work of the curatorial team in Special Collections, then a core group of five people. Nineteen different people have contributed written posts to Historical How-To’s, not including all the other people who have joined in communal activities such as the Halloween ghost tour, papermaking, the Christmas party, hillwalking, and the blog choir. […]

  • Reading the Collections, week 25: Brides Wedding Book | Echoes from the Vault
    Thursday 9 July 2015, 11.58am

    […] been booked (St Salvator’s Chapel, followed by a reception at Lower and Upper College Hall); the Library Choir have agreed to sing; my dress and that of my bridesmaid have been ordered (both from Enchanted in […]


Leave a reply

By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by this website.


Enter your email address here to receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 6,499 other subscribers.