Meet your rare anatomy books

Friday 1 February 2019

On 21st January we held our first outreach session of the year: Meet your rare anatomy books. This event gave staff and students from the School of Medicine (and a couple of Library Directors!) the chance to view and discuss some of the older anatomical and medical books and manuscripts which we hold in Special Collections.

Discussion with expert input from Professor David Sinclair
The manuscript addition of a fist, pointing to “Signa pleuresis”, in Niccolò Falcucci’s Sermones medicinales septem. St Andrews University Library, Typ IP.A83DF

We began in the fifteenth century with Niccolò Falcucci’s (d. 1411/12) Sermones medicinales septem, printed in 1481-84. This volume belonged to William Scheves (d. 1497), Archbishop of St Andrews, and has scarce marginalia throughout, including a large fist pointing to “Signa pleuresis” on leaf h7r. In the early 1470s Scheves received an annual court pension for his services as a physician, but little is known about his medical training. His ownership and annotation of this (and other) medical texts substantiates his interest in this field.

We then toured through the following centuries (with discussions of whether or not a rust coloured mark on a page was blood or foxing), ending in the nineteenth century with a letter of 1862 from William Ramsay (1806-1865), Professor of Humanity at the University of Glasgow, to James David Forbes (1809-1868), Principal of the United College, St Andrews. In this letter Ramsay discussed the attitude of Glasgow University towards female education, in relation to the case of Elizabeth Garrett (1836-1917), who had been allowed to matriculate at St Andrews that year. “I have convened with the greater number of my colleagues and have found them all of the same opinion, viz. that the proposal was monstrous, and that, independent of any legal subtleties, it ought to be resisted on the head grounds of public decency”, for she might, in anatomy classes, “be surrounded by a crowd of very young men – many of them altogether destitute of any kind of delicacy or refinement.  The idea is so revolting that it is difficult to imagine that it could have been seriously entertained”. Her name was later scored out from the matriculation register when the Senatus Academicus rescinded her admission.

Letter from William Ramsay to James David Forbes, where he notes the monstrous proposal of a female in an anatomy class, where she might find herself “surrounded by a crowd of very young men – many of them altogether destitute of any kind of delicacy or refinement”. St Andrews University Library, msdep7 incoming letters 1862 no. 175 a-b

A repeat session has been requested for the summer. Here are some of the highlights from the event; we hope you enjoy them.

If the peeling layers of skin are a bit too gruesome, then one can always choose to focus upon the artistic background, with its houses, boats, and water birds. Adriaan van de Spiegel, Opera quæ extant, omnia, St Andrews University Library, Scot QM21.S6
The first page of vol. 1 of David Orme’s notes on midwifery, headed “Introductory Lecture of the Rise and Progress of the obstetric Art.”. St Andrews University Library, ms39067.

Two manuscript volumes of lectures on midwifery by David Orme (1727-1812) were recently added to our collections, being purchased in July 2018; this is only the second time we’ve had them out on display. Orme was a native of Scotland, who held the office of man-midwife extraordinary to the City of London Lying-in Hospital, and lectured at Guy’s Hospital. There author is not identified within the text itself, but the contemporary labels on the spines are lettered “Orme’s Midwifery”. A rough date to the lectures can be found in the first lecture, where Orme outlines the historical basis of the obstetric art, quoting authors from earlier times up to ‘Dr. Watts’. This is presumably Giles Watts (1725-1792), one of William Smellie’s pupils, and the author of Reflections on Slow and Painful Labours, published 1755. As Orme refers to the works as ‘lately published’, it seems likely his lectures were written c. 1755-1760.

The mention of Dr. Watt’s lately published book, of which Orme is quite dismissive: “Dr: Watts lately publish’d a Book on Midwifery, but it is not very valuable & indeed his Practice is scarce warrantable: he orders ye. Scooping of ye. O’s Tincæ. wch: only torments ye. Patient, & seems rather disadvantageous than useful. Upon the whole, Gentlemen I recommend for your Perusal, Mauriceau, La Mot, Daventer, Portal, Smellie, Gifford & Chapman.” St Andrews University Library, ms39067
Plates of the human skeleton in Andreas Vesalius’ De humani corporis fabrica; that on the left is a larger engraving from Boerhaave’s edition of 1725, tipped in to the 1568 edition. It was possibly added as a teaching aid. St Andrews University Library, Sim QM21.V2

First published in 1543, Andreas VesaliusDe humani corporis fabrica was a major advancement in the history of anatomy. Prior to the publication of Vesalius’ work, Galen’s (129A.D.-c. 200/216) observation on anatomy had been dominant. Galen had used animal corpses for his observations, but Vesalius used human cadavers, and was thus able to correct some of Galen’s errors. The work is beautifully illustrated with detailed woodcuts. The St Andrews copy includes several larger, more detailed engravings from a copy of Herman Boerhaave‘s edition of 1725 pasted in beside or over the corresponding woodcuts. This copy, published in 1568, belonged to Thomas Simson (1696-1764), the first Chandos Professor of Medicine at St Salvator’s College, University of St Andrews, and it’s therefore possible that he added the larger engravings as an aid to teaching.

The use of cut-out areas between plates adds a three-dimensional effect the plates of Alexander Ramsay’s Anatomy of the heart, cranium, and brain. Here we can see the view provided from plates VII-IX, and from plate IX-XII. St Andrews University Library, sf QM25.R2

In 1812 Alexander Ramsay (1754?-1824), lecturer on anatomy and physiology in Edinburgh, published his Description of plates of the brain, with direction for the development of that organ by dissection; together with observations on its various parts. “The rapid sale of the first edition of this Work, and the approbation with which it has been received” encouraged Ramsay to publish a second edition the following year, under the title Anatomy of the heart, cranium, and brain …, and it is this edition of which St Andrews has a copy. Ramsay did not trust artists of the day to “adhere so strictly to those minutiæ on which anatomical works become chiefly valuable”, and so he drew the illustrations for the plates himself; they were finished in aquatint by Robert Scott (1777-1841), engraver. Plates VII to XI are particularly ingenuous, for they contain a series of cut-out areas to reveal sections of the plates below, simulating the stages of an actual dissection.

Table IV in vol. 1 of George Spratt’s Obstetric Tables, with its five figures, showing the form of the abdomen and breasts in a virgin, and the 3rd, 6th, 7th, and 9th months of pregnancy. St Andrews University Library, s RG526.T2S7

This means of representing spatial relationships in a paper volume is also found in George Spratt’s (1784-1840) Obstetric Tables. First published in 1833 in a single volume, our copy is the third edition, “considerably enlarged and improved”, published in two volumes in 1838. Spratt was a member of the Royal College of Surgeons, and describes himself on the title page as “Surgeon-Accoucheur”, that’s to say, a male midwife. The work was intended as a teaching aid, and as such the many colour illustrations have flaps (some as many as four or five layers), offering a ‘3D’ image of the different stages of pregnancy. At a time when it was becoming difficult for medical students to gain clinical experience such an aid would have been invaluable.

The medical testimonial for Edward Jenner, recommended by Caleb Parry and John Hickes, UYUY350

Another of our manuscripts on display was the medical testimonial for Edward Jenner (1749-1823). The University of St Andrews did not offer formal medical training in the 18th century, but rather offered the degree via medical testimonial. In order to obtain a degree from St Andrews someone simply required recommendations from two reputable doctors. Caleb Parry (1755-1822) and John Hickes (d. 1808), Jenner’s colleagues, acted for him in 1792; after twenty years’ experience of general practice and surgery, Jenner could now style himself physician and surgeon.

An illustration of the cowpox as it appeared on the hand of dairymaid Sarah Nelmes. It was matter taken from this sore which was inserted into the arm of 8-year-old James Phipps, proving to be a successful inoculation. Edward Jenner, An inquiry into the cause and effects of the variolæ vaccinæ, St Andrews University Library, s RC183.C7J4

Jenner is famous for inventing the vaccination for smallpox. Testing the theory that milkmaids who suffered with the mild disease of cowpox never succumbed to smallpox, a great killer in the 18th century, in 1796 he carried out the first documented experiment, inserting pus from a cowpox pustule into an incision on 8-year-old James Phipps (1788-1853). The test was successful, but it was another two years, following further testing, before he privately published his results in An inquiry into the causes and effects of the variolae vaccinae. St Andrews doesn’t own a first edition of this work, but we brought out our 1884 facsimile reprint of the 1800 second edition.

Is this a spattering of blood, evidence of Spratt’s Obstetric Tables being used in a clinical environment? Or is it merely foxing? We suspect the latter, but you choose….

Briony Harding
Assistant Rare Books Librarian

Elizabeth Henderson
Rare Books Librarian

Related topics

Share this story

Leave a reply

By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by this website.


Enter your email address here to receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 6,493 other subscribers.